Monday, March 8, 2010

Noonday Friends by Mary Stolz


1966 Newbery Honor

A humorous portrait of a happy family and their relationships with the rest of the world.

Comments by: Bayleigh B., Claire E., Emily G., Sidney W., Laney T., Victoria M., Megan E., Taylor M., 5th grade

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

This book was about a girl named Franny. Her family wasn't rich nor poor but her father couldn't get a job. She feels like she is losing her best friend to wealthy Lila Wembleton. In the end, her father gets a job and Franny gets her friend back. She also makes a new friend, too.

I thought it was good. It was dramatic, sad, happy, and in all a wonderful book.

1 star

by Bayleigh B., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

Franny Davis lives in New York. Her and her friend Simone have fights over things that are silly, and she wants to be Simone's friend. She worries that she will lose Simone to Lila, a very rich girl. In the end, Franny is friends with both Simone and Lila.

I think it was very good and dramatic. I really liked it.

3 stars

by Claire E., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

A girl named Franny has a dad who can't find a job. She also has a friend who thinks a girl named Lila is rich. Her brother's birthday is coming up, so she makes him a present. His name is Marshall and he has a small birthday party on his birthday. Even though Franny has friend problems, she soon is able to make up with them and her dad finds a great job he likes.

I thought it was a great book. It had a touch of sadness in it and joyful through the whole book.

3 stars

by Emily G., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

It is where a poor girl lives with her family in a dark apartment and her dad keeps losing his job. Simone Orgella and Franny quarell quite a bit so Simone makes friends with Rich Lila. Then finally her dad gets a job. Marshall gets a birthday party and she lives happily ever after.

It was kind of boring but it ended with a happy every after.

by Sidney W., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

Franny Davis is a eleven year old girl who's Mom works full-time and her dad is an artist who can't keep a job. She has two brothers she has to take care of and never has time to play with Simone. Simone has another friend Lila who is rich and Franny feels like Lila is a better friend than her.

It was a great book about friendship.

4 stars

by Laney T., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

I thought that the book was very interesting and I would recommend it to anyone who likes drama books.

4 stars

by Victoria M., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

It was a really good book about friendship problems. It was funny and made me want to read it again.

3 stars

by Megan E., 5th grade

Anonymous said...

I think that the book was good. I loved how it had a lot of action.

3 stars

by Taylor M., 5th grade